How the top NFL preview magazines view the Redskins

For as long as I can remember, I’ve obtained NFL preview magazines every year to break down rosters, analyze team pickups, look over league-wide predictions, and on top of it all, see how the Redskins stacked up against the rest of the league and the NFC East.

That obsession of buying these magazines continues to this day, with fewer to choose from than in years past but just enough to get me ready for training camp in the doldrums of the sports calendar.

The top paperbound prognosticators remaining are Lindy’s, Athlon and Sporting News.

Let’s take a look at how they predicted the Redskins to finish in the NFC East this season. Spoiler alert: It’s not first. Or second. Or third.

Lindy’s Sports

Prediction: 4th NFC East
Power Rankings: None
Analysis: “Not far behind in competitive division, they can climb higher with more consistency from RGIII.” – Howard Balzer
Notable Anecdote: Trent Williams was ranked as the 12th best left tackle in the NFL. No other Redskins offensive lineman was ranked in the top 10 at their position.

Athlon

Athlon Sports

Prediction: 4th NFC East
Power Rankings: 16th NFC
Analysis: “Jay Gruden tasked with keeping RGIII happy and healthy.”
Notable Anecdote: I’m not sure how the magazine’s player rankings came about but they are courtesy of Ourlads’ NFL Scouting Services. Robert Griffin III was ranked the 24th best quarterback in the NFL. Alfred Morris was ranked the 21st best running back. Trent Williams was ranked the best offensive tackle. Akeem Jordan was ranked the 19th best inside linebacker while neither Brian Orakpo nor Ryan Kerrigan ranked in the top 20 outside linebackers. DeAngelo Hall was not ranked in the top 30 cornerbacks.

2014ProFB_Cov_REG5.indd

Sporting News

Prediction: 4th NFC East
Power Rankings: 15th NFC, 26th overall
Analysis: “The Redskins could easily shoot up and win this division, but let’s curb the expectations in the first year under coach Jay Gruden. The goal this year is to get Robert Griffin III right. Plenty of holes remaining in the defense.”
Notable Anecdote: Sporting News predicts nose tackle Chris Baker as this year’s team breakout candidate.

—– UPDATED: JULY 12TH —–

USA Today

Prediction: 2nd NFC East (7-9) – via Nate Davis
Power Rankings: 16th NFC, 30th overall
Analysis: “If line and RGIII’s knee hold up, this offense will be hard to slow down. But defense might be year away.”
Notable Anecdote(s): Contrary to the 30th overall ranking given to them earlier in the magazine, the Redskins are named the top NFC team on the rise in the conference’s preview section. Maggie Hendricks ranked Jay Gruden as the seventh best (out of seven) head coaching hire this offseason. Jim Corbett predicts Griffin will be named the NFL Comeback Player of the Year after the 2014 season.

unnamed

Pro Football Now

Prediction: 4th NFC East (4-12)
Power Rankings: 16th NFC, 32nd overall
Analysis: “A quick turnaround is not out of the question for the Redskins in the up-for-grabs NFC East. But Robert Griffin must try harder than ever to avoid unnecessary hits, and newcomer DeSean Jackson must keep his head on straight. A fast start is quite possible with winnable games against the Texans and Jaguars the first two weeks of the season.”
Notable Anecdote(s): In a Top 50 player power ranking, Alfred Morris was the only Redskin listed, coming in at number 39. “Re-establishing RGIII” was named the sixth biggest storyline heading into the NFL season. And in a list classifying organizations as “the elite,” “good but not great,” “stuck in the middle,” “bad but could be worse,” and “the clueless,” the Redskins were classified as one of the nine “clueless” franchises.

3 comments

  1. One names TW as the 12 best left tackle and the other names him the best overall tackle in the game? RG3 is the 24th best QB but worthy of the cover? 20 better RB’s in the league than Morris but another publication has him the 39th best player in the league? Wow!

  2. The disparities not only among these “expert” publications but even within some of them, exposes them for their functional uselessness and even what appears to be their downright careless and ill-advised predictions. Entertaining and worthy of bathtub reading … perhaps. But worthy of consideration for serious prognosticating and even an exposure of informed and objective evaluation … No way!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s